Tuesday, April 29, 2025

Memoirs of Hadrian

 Memoirs of Hadrian by Marguerite Yourcenar is a beautiful, complex novel from the perspective of a Roman emperor. Its subject matter is similar to I, Claudius, but the voice is much more abstract, more methodical, more contemplative. Eschewing specific details and events for a more philosophical reminiscence, the voice reminded me of Marilynne Robinson's Gilead: it was thoughtful and hypnotic. The difference, of course, is that August Hadrian is a much different person than Rev. John Ames. Historically, Hadrian is widely considered one of the "good" Roman emperors (especially compared to Nero or Caligula), but from a late-Modern perspective, that's not a high bar.

One is fooled by the voice, though. A surface reading of Memoirs of Hadrian does seem to present a milder, art-loving, anti-colonial statesman. We are lulled into this sense as Hadrian pulls away from the frontiers (his famous "wall" in Britain meant to be the cap on expansionism, for example). He loves the Greeks; he makes peace with the Parthians. But there's something sinister behind the barely described events. How old was Antinous when Hadrian "adopted" him as a lover? For that matter, what was the age difference? How did he suppress the Jewish revolt? How consensual were his myriad "loves"? How "accidental" was his blinding of a slave with his pen? Beyond the aesthetic prose, the novel hides a deeply unreliable narrator. 

Tuesday, April 8, 2025

Drive Your Plow over the Bones of the Dead

 Drive Your Plow over the Bones of the Dead by Olga Tokarczuk solidifies its author's place as one of the very best writers alive today. Ostensibly a mystery novel, it inhabits its genre comfortably while transcending it every page. The compelling-but-unsurprising plot unfolds as several bodies turn up in a remote Polish village. The old, eccentric narrator is ignored as she offers increasingly outlandish culprits for the police to investigate. All of this is fine--and well constructed--but it provides only the bare bones of the narrative. The novel is fleshed out with its many masterful motifs: ecology, astrology, religion, ageing, and the works of William Blake, from whom the book takes its title. A deserving Nobel Prize winner, Tokarczuk is a singular, brilliant mind. The three books of hers I've read so far are wildly different in terms of subject matter, form, and even genre, but she maintains a top-tier, crystalline regard for craft and detail. The chapters, sentences, and even word capitalization all serve a remarkably complete voice. Janina Duszejko, the narrator, is one of the most complete and original characters in any work of fiction, in any era.